5.0 out of 5 stars Exceeded My Expectations — Safe, Soft, and Actually Leak-Proof!

2026-02-23    -Adetta

As a parent who’s very conscious about ingredients and skin safety, I’m always on the lookout for products that are both effective and non-toxic. These SmartyPants Pull Up Style Diapers have genuinely impressed me.First off, the EWG Verified label is what caught my eye — it’s rare to find pull-ups that meet those clean standards. Once they arrived, I could immediately tell the difference: the material feels softer and more breathable than most brands we’ve tried. My toddler has very sensitive skin, and after switching to these, we’ve had zero irritation or redness.The quilted 360° waistband is a game-changer. It fits snugly without being too tight, so it moves with my little one through all the running, climbing, and dancing. We haven’t had a single leak overnight (which is saying a lot after testing other “eco-friendly” brands that couldn’t make it through).I also love that the pull-up design makes potty training easier — my toddler feels more independent pulling them up and down, and the side tear-away seams are convenient for quick changes.Overall, these diapers hit every mark: safe ingredients, comfortable fit, great absorbency, and a company that clearly cares about both babies and the planet.Highly recommend to any parent looking for a plant-based, trustworthy diaper that doesn’t sacrifice performance.

3.0 out of 5 stars Size 4 runs small

2025-12-29    -Gandalf Baggins

The quality is definitely good and there were no problems with the absorbancy, but the sizing was way off for my 24 pound daughter, who should have been a size 4. The elastic was so tight it left red marks on her hips and waist. I recommend sizing up. It was just disappointing to have this problem after spending so much money on them.

1.0 out of 5 stars Are they really clean as advertised??

2025-12-23    -Ananda Manesh

I love the intention behind making these diapers. They look great! However:SIZE: They run small compared to other diapers. At the time of writing this review, my baby can comfortably wear a size 4 diaper based on her height and weight, but I get her size 5 diapers for the added volume. Even the size 5 was tight on her.SMELL: My biggest issue is that they reeked of chemical. I am not sure if this was an issue with the make itself, or with the storage/shipping/handling but i had to throw them out.NOT EASY TO TEAR OFF: The side stitches look great but they don't tear off well. You need to be mindful when you try to take it off as you may accidentally press on your baby’s skin and hurt them. I have seen other companies implement this successfully, not sure if this is due to the materials used in making these diapers.

5.0 out of 5 stars Great

2025-12-23    -Felicia Miller

Work great and hold just as well as the diapers do. Very thin, just like the diapers but comfortable. I did have to size up one than the diapers, they run a little small.

5.0 out of 5 stars Great

2025-12-26    -Felicia Miller

Work great and hold just as well as the diapers do. Very thin, just like the diapers but comfortable. I did have to size up one than the diapers, they run a little small.

5.0 out of 5 stars Exceeded My Expectations — Safe, Soft, and Actually Leak-Proof!

2026-01-09    -Adetta

As a parent who’s very conscious about ingredients and skin safety, I’m always on the lookout for products that are both effective and non-toxic. These SmartyPants Pull Up Style Diapers have genuinely impressed me.First off, the EWG Verified label is what caught my eye — it’s rare to find pull-ups that meet those clean standards. Once they arrived, I could immediately tell the difference: the material feels softer and more breathable than most brands we’ve tried. My toddler has very sensitive skin, and after switching to these, we’ve had zero irritation or redness.The quilted 360° waistband is a game-changer. It fits snugly without being too tight, so it moves with my little one through all the running, climbing, and dancing. We haven’t had a single leak overnight (which is saying a lot after testing other “eco-friendly” brands that couldn’t make it through).I also love that the pull-up design makes potty training easier — my toddler feels more independent pulling them up and down, and the side tear-away seams are convenient for quick changes.Overall, these diapers hit every mark: safe ingredients, comfortable fit, great absorbency, and a company that clearly cares about both babies and the planet.Highly recommend to any parent looking for a plant-based, trustworthy diaper that doesn’t sacrifice performance.

4.0 out of 5 stars Good option but room for improvement!

2025-12-29    -SLTelescope

I love healthy baby, but they struggle with size (both diapers and pull ups)!PROS:- Softness- Durable/Absorbent- Non-toxic quality (of course!!)- No scent- Pull option for younger kiddoCONS:- Hard to tell front from back- Tight waist!!My 15mos old is 22lbs and on the taller side (65-70 percentile) and these leave marks on his hips. The waistband is “tall” so we fold this down to minimize any discomfort.

5.0 out of 5 stars Soft, clean and affordable!

2026-02-15    -Bryan

Loving these pull ups. We ordered the size 4 and the waist was pretty tight. Sized up for the 5 and it’s got a good waist and there don’t seem to be any leaking problems right now. Very soft and love that they are EWG verified.

5.0 out of 5 stars The best pull-ups/diapers

2026-02-03    -Adrienne

These are the best diapers/pullups I have found. They are EWG certified and are thinner than most. Plus they don’t have a weird smell when they are full of pee. I have not had a problem with leaking either. They are expensive, but l feel like it’s worth it because of the high-quality.

3.0 out of 5 stars Size 4 runs small

2026-02-25    -Gandalf Baggins

The quality is definitely good and there were no problems with the absorbancy, but the sizing was way off for my 24 pound daughter, who should have been a size 4. The elastic was so tight it left red marks on her hips and waist. I recommend sizing up. It was just disappointing to have this problem after spending so much money on them.